Your agency is working if it can show, every month, the repairs it booked and the full spend behind them, matched to ROs in your own system, not clicks or impressions. If the report can’t produce a booked-jobs number, ask for one, then check the accounts yourself. A 30-minute audit will tell you most of what you need.
The test: booked repairs and spend
Every marketing report should answer two things: how many repairs the work put in your bays, and what you spent to get them, ads and fee together. Divide the spend by the jobs and you have cost per booked job. That’s the number to hold against what a job is worth to you.
Say you spend $3,000 a month on ads and pay a $1,500 fee, so $4,500 in total. Your average RO is $4,200 and you keep 40% as gross profit, so each job leaves about $1,680 before marketing.
If the work brought in 6 booked jobs, each one cost $750 and left about $930. That’s working. If it brought in 2, each one cost $2,250 to win, more than it made, however good the click numbers look.
You can run your own version in our repair opportunity calculator. For a real reference point, AE Collision Center in Tampa spent $1,187.27 on Google Ads in August 2026, and the shop reports 9 closed jobs that month. That’s about $132 in ad spend per reported job, before our fee.
It’s one shop in one market, not a benchmark. We walk through the full math in what one booked job really cost a Tampa shop.
If the agency can’t produce a booked-jobs number at all, one of two things is true. Either the work is fine and the measurement is broken, or the work is broken and nobody can tell. Either way, you’re paying blind.
What the monthly report needs
A useful report fits on one page, and every line traces back to a source you can check.
| Line | What it should show | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Ad spend | Spend by channel, with the fee on its own line | The ad account itself |
| Calls | Total calls and first-time callers, by source | Call tracking |
| Answered vs missed | Missed calls by hour and day | Call tracking |
| Forms and texts | How many came in, and whether each got a reply | Website and inbox |
| Estimates | Estimates written from those calls and forms | Your estimating system |
| Booked jobs | ROs opened, listed by RO number | Your management system |
| Repair revenue | The total of those ROs | Your management system |
| Cost per booked job | Ad spend plus fee, divided by booked jobs | Simple division |
Under the table, two short lines: what changed this month, and what changes next month.
Watch one word: conversions. In Google Ads, a conversion is an action, such as a call or a form submission, and one driver who calls twice and fills out a form can count three times. Conversions help run the account, but they are not customers and they are not jobs.
Red flags worth acting on
One red flag can be a slow month. Three is a pattern.
- The report leads with impressions, clicks, click-through rate, reach or “engagement,” and booked jobs are missing or buried.
- You don’t have admin access to your own ad account, or the ads run in an account the agency opened and bills through. If you leave, the history leaves with them.
- A 12-month contract with auto-renewal, a cancellation fee or a 90-day notice period.
- Monthly “SEO work” with nothing to point at: no pages written, no profile fixes, no list of changes.
- Leads you never see. The report shows a lead count, but no names, numbers, recordings or form entries you can check.
- Blame on your front desk with no data behind it. “Your team isn’t closing” should come with recordings, missed-call times and the leads in question.
- Conversions that count junk, like page views, clicks on the directions button, or calls too short to be real conversations.
- Search terms you’d never pay for: “auto body jobs,” “body shop supplies,” “how to fix a dent,” or towns you don’t serve.
Be careful with benchmark comparisons too. WordStream and LocaliQ’s 2026 Google Ads benchmarks, built on 13,474 US campaigns from April 2025 to March 2026, put the average cost per lead at $29.96 for the automotive repair, service and parts category.
That average covers the whole auto repair and parts category, not collision shops alone. Beating it tells you nothing about booked repairs.
What a good partner shows
The green flags are the red flags turned around. Score your current agency against this list:
- You log in to Google Ads, your Business Profile and analytics with your own email, as admin or owner.
- The report starts with booked jobs and RO numbers, then works back to spend.
- They ask for your RO list each month, or help you log the source on every RO.
- They send you specific calls to hear: “Tuesday, 12:40, rang nine times, caller hung up.”
- They tell you what they cut and why, like “paint supply” searches or a town across the river.
- They know your average RO, your capacity and the work you want more of.
- They pull spend back when you’re booked out, before you have to ask.
- Month-to-month terms, so they keep your business by earning it.
That’s the standard we hold ourselves to. The shop owns its ad account, website and data, the agreement is month-to-month, and every month the shop sees its calls, booked jobs and the spend behind them.
A 30-minute audit you can run
Do this yourself, with your own login, before the next meeting. Have last month’s report in front of you.
- Log in to Google Ads (5 minutes). Go to Admin, then Access and security, and check that you’re listed with admin access and that billing is on your card. If you can’t log in at all, stop there, because that’s the finding.
- Read the search terms (5 minutes). Open the search terms report under Insights and reports, set it to the last 30 days, and read the top 50. Count anything you’d never pay for, then check under Goals which actions count as conversions.
- Log in to your Business Profile (5 minutes). Under Business Profile settings, then People and access, you should be the primary owner. Call the number on the listing and make sure it rings your shop.
- Listen to 5 recorded calls (10 minutes). Pick them yourself from last month, not the ones the agency picks. For each one, note whether it was a new customer, whether a person answered, and whether the caller got an estimate time.
- Match 10 leads to ROs (5 minutes). Take 10 names or phone numbers from the report and look them up in your management system. Sort them: became an RO, estimate only, never came in, or can’t be found at all.
Read the results plainly. No login or no ownership means fixing access comes before anything else. Junk in the search terms means you’re paying for clicks that can’t become repairs.
Good callers who hit voicemail are your side of the problem, and that’s fixable. Leads you can’t find at all need an explanation, and so do recordings you can’t get to.
If you’d like a second set of eyes, our free 20-minute shop review covers the same ground. The three fixes you leave with are yours to keep, even if you never hire us.
Bring these to the next meeting
Send these ahead of time, in writing:
- Show last month’s booked jobs by RO number, and the full spend behind them.
- Make the shop admin on Google Ads, analytics, Tag Manager, the call tracking account, the Business Profile and the domain.
- List the search terms you excluded this month and the ones you’re watching.
- Show missed calls by hour and day for the last 30 days.
- Say what changes next month, and which number should move.
- Explain what stays with the shop if we part ways.
Give them two weeks. A partner that tracks booked jobs can send most of this in a day. One that needs a month to build the report wasn’t tracking booked jobs.
How to leave cleanly
Get access first. Give notice second.
- Get admin access to everything while things are still friendly: Google Ads, analytics, Tag Manager, Search Console, the Business Profile, any Meta ad account, the website’s hosting and admin login, and the domain registrar. The domain should be in the shop’s name.
- Sort out the call tracking numbers. If the number on your listing, website and ads lives in the agency’s account, it stops ringing when they cancel it, so ask to transfer the numbers or switch to numbers you own before you leave.
- Download the history: 12 months of reports, call recordings and lead lists.
- Read the contract for the notice period, any cancellation fee and who owns the website files.
- Plan the first month after. If the ads ran in the agency’s own account, you’ll start a new one, and it takes a few weeks to settle, so decide who runs it from day one.
- Remove their access and change the passwords once the handoff is done.
The domain and the tracking numbers are the two that catch shops out. Both can take weeks to untangle once the relationship has gone cold.
What to do this week
- Log in to Google Ads and your Business Profile with your own email and confirm you’re admin and primary owner.
- Circle every line in last month’s report that isn’t spend, calls, estimates, booked jobs or repair revenue.
- Listen to five recorded calls and match ten leads to ROs.
- Email the agency your six asks and set a meeting date.
- Start logging the source on every RO you open, so next month you have your own numbers.
Questions owners ask
How long should a new agency get before you judge it?
Access and tracking should be done in the first two weeks. You should see spend, calls and booked jobs in the first full month, and a cost per booked job you trust by month three. If month two ends with no booked-jobs line, more time isn’t the fix, and our guide to the first 90 days with a marketing partner shows what should have happened by then.
The agency blames our front desk. Who’s right?
The recordings settle it. Listen to ten calls from last month: wrong-service and out-of-area callers point to the targeting, while good callers who rang out or never got an estimate time point to the desk. Why collision leads don’t turn into booked jobs covers the fixes on both sides.
What’s a good cost per booked job?
That’s set by your average RO and your gross profit, so work it out from your own numbers. If a job leaves $1,680 before marketing, $750 per booked job works and $2,250 doesn’t. Count the fee as well as ad spend, and judge the trend over three months, not one.

